{
  "provenance": {
    "title": "COMPOSE: Molecular Generation and Optimization with a Reusable Stochastic Rewrite Process",
    "filename": "19340_COMPOSE_Molecular_Genera.pdf",
    "sha256": "6d21256114c1f046b3143e5112172be93212e0e170b3403378fc74fb5c5f87cf",
    "pages": 35,
    "status": "Manuscript under review",
    "received": "2026-11-05",
    "tables": {
      "reference": 6,
      "fragments": 1,
      "qed": 10,
      "qedContext": 22,
      "pmo": 2,
      "pmoAuc": 11,
      "docking": 3,
      "superstructureAblation": 7,
      "lockedSelection": 15,
      "programAblation": 18,
      "reachability": 12
    }
  },
  "results": {
    "source": "/papers/compose.pdf",
    "reference": [
      {
        "method": "Uniform successors",
        "nll": 6.25
      },
      {
        "method": "Empirical edit-family frequencies",
        "nll": 5.37
      },
      {
        "method": "Learned family, uniform successor",
        "nll": 5.17
      },
      {
        "method": "Empirical family, learned successor",
        "nll": 4.1
      },
      {
        "method": "Full learned reference",
        "nll": 3.9
      }
    ],
    "fragments": [
      {
        "task": "Motif extension",
        "compose": {
          "quality": [
            42.63,
            0.38
          ],
          "uniqueness": [
            93.63,
            0.6
          ],
          "diversity": [
            0.664,
            0.001
          ],
          "validity": [
            100,
            0
          ]
        },
        "ivg": {
          "quality": [
            39.27,
            1.078
          ],
          "uniqueness": [
            96.83,
            0.29
          ],
          "diversity": [
            0.62,
            0.005
          ],
          "validity": [
            68.97,
            0.759
          ]
        },
        "genmol": {
          "quality": [
            30.1,
            0.4
          ],
          "uniqueness": [
            77.5,
            0.1
          ],
          "diversity": [
            0.617,
            0.002
          ],
          "validity": [
            82.9,
            0.1
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "task": "Superstructure generation",
        "compose": {
          "quality": [
            39.03,
            3.09
          ],
          "uniqueness": [
            97.33,
            0.61
          ],
          "diversity": [
            0.725,
            0.001
          ],
          "validity": [
            100,
            0
          ]
        },
        "ivg": {
          "quality": [
            27.43,
            0.953
          ],
          "uniqueness": [
            99.41,
            0.157
          ],
          "diversity": [
            0.73,
            0.001
          ],
          "validity": [
            75.7,
            0.898
          ]
        },
        "genmol": {
          "quality": [
            34.8,
            1.0
          ],
          "uniqueness": [
            83.6,
            1.0
          ],
          "diversity": [
            0.599,
            0.009
          ],
          "validity": [
            97.5,
            0.9
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "task": "Linker design",
        "compose": {
          "quality": [
            31.53,
            1.4
          ],
          "uniqueness": [
            81.03,
            0.35
          ],
          "diversity": [
            0.564,
            0.002
          ],
          "validity": [
            100,
            0
          ]
        },
        "ivg": {
          "quality": [
            22.33,
            1.25
          ],
          "uniqueness": [
            84.76,
            1.62
          ],
          "diversity": [
            0.52,
            0.004
          ],
          "validity": [
            60.37,
            0.573
          ]
        },
        "genmol": {
          "quality": [
            4.3,
            0.4
          ],
          "uniqueness": [
            93.9,
            null
          ],
          "diversity": [
            0.529,
            0.002
          ],
          "validity": [
            16.7,
            0.2
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "task": "Scaffold morphing",
        "compose": {
          "quality": [
            31.53,
            1.4
          ],
          "uniqueness": [
            81.03,
            0.35
          ],
          "diversity": [
            0.564,
            0.002
          ],
          "validity": [
            100,
            0
          ]
        },
        "ivg": {
          "quality": [
            22.33,
            1.25
          ],
          "uniqueness": [
            84.76,
            1.62
          ],
          "diversity": [
            0.52,
            0.004
          ],
          "validity": [
            60.37,
            0.573
          ]
        },
        "genmol": {
          "quality": [
            4.3,
            0.4
          ],
          "uniqueness": [
            93.9,
            null
          ],
          "diversity": [
            0.529,
            0.002
          ],
          "validity": [
            16.7,
            0.2
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "task": "Scaffold decoration",
        "compose": {
          "quality": [
            36.7,
            1.8
          ],
          "uniqueness": [
            93.67,
            0.83
          ],
          "diversity": [
            0.563,
            0.002
          ],
          "validity": [
            100,
            0
          ]
        },
        "ivg": {
          "quality": [
            36.37,
            1.096
          ],
          "uniqueness": [
            88.58,
            1.13
          ],
          "diversity": [
            0.56,
            0.003
          ],
          "validity": [
            90.7,
            0.616
          ]
        },
        "genmol": {
          "quality": [
            31.8,
            0.5
          ],
          "uniqueness": [
            82.7,
            1.8
          ],
          "diversity": [
            0.591,
            0.001
          ],
          "validity": [
            96.6,
            0.8
          ]
        }
      }
    ],
    "pmoSummary": [
      {
        "method": "COMPOSE",
        "final": 0.563,
        "auc": 0.482
      },
      {
        "method": "GenMol",
        "final": 0.542,
        "auc": 0.537
      },
      {
        "method": "InVirtuoGen",
        "final": 0.532,
        "auc": 0.45
      },
      {
        "method": "REINVENT",
        "final": 0.531,
        "auc": 0.419
      },
      {
        "method": "Graph-GA",
        "final": 0.53,
        "auc": 0.439
      }
    ],
    "pmo": [
      {
        "objective": "Albuterol similarity",
        "compose": [
          0.782,
          0.02
        ],
        "genmol": [
          0.567,
          0.01
        ],
        "ivg": [
          0.566,
          0.01
        ],
        "reinvent": [
          0.583,
          0.03
        ],
        "graphga": [
          0.508,
          0.06
        ]
      },
      {
        "objective": "Amlodipine MPO",
        "compose": [
          0.539,
          0.035
        ],
        "genmol": [
          0.571,
          0.01
        ],
        "ivg": [
          0.536,
          0.01
        ],
        "reinvent": [
          0.496,
          0.01
        ],
        "graphga": [
          0.539,
          0.01
        ]
      },
      {
        "objective": "Celecoxib rediscovery",
        "compose": [
          0.335,
          0.053
        ],
        "genmol": [
          0.456,
          0.01
        ],
        "ivg": [
          0.413,
          0.03
        ],
        "reinvent": [
          0.426,
          0.03
        ],
        "graphga": [
          0.385,
          0.01
        ]
      },
      {
        "objective": "Deco hop",
        "compose": [
          0.586,
          0.01
        ],
        "genmol": [
          0.641,
          0.03
        ],
        "ivg": [
          0.612,
          0.0
        ],
        "reinvent": [
          0.591,
          0.01
        ],
        "graphga": [
          0.607,
          0.01
        ]
      },
      {
        "objective": "DRD2",
        "compose": [
          0.979,
          0.018
        ],
        "genmol": [
          0.984,
          0.0
        ],
        "ivg": [
          0.993,
          0.01
        ],
        "reinvent": [
          0.975,
          0.01
        ],
        "graphga": [
          0.999,
          0.01
        ]
      },
      {
        "objective": "Fexofenadine MPO",
        "compose": [
          0.751,
          0.043
        ],
        "genmol": [
          0.731,
          0.01
        ],
        "ivg": [
          0.702,
          0.02
        ],
        "reinvent": [
          0.695,
          0.01
        ],
        "graphga": [
          0.699,
          0.0
        ]
      },
      {
        "objective": "GSK3B",
        "compose": [
          0.535,
          0.065
        ],
        "genmol": [
          0.673,
          0.01
        ],
        "ivg": [
          0.572,
          0.09
        ],
        "reinvent": [
          0.773,
          0.08
        ],
        "graphga": [
          0.59,
          0.03
        ]
      },
      {
        "objective": "Isomers C7H8N2O2",
        "compose": [
          0.911,
          0.029
        ],
        "genmol": [
          0.485,
          0.05
        ],
        "ivg": [
          0.597,
          0.05
        ],
        "reinvent": [
          0.879,
          0.04
        ],
        "graphga": [
          0.846,
          0.02
        ]
      },
      {
        "objective": "Isomers C9H10N2O2PF2Cl",
        "compose": [
          0.895,
          0.064
        ],
        "genmol": [
          0.553,
          0.04
        ],
        "ivg": [
          0.672,
          0.1
        ],
        "reinvent": [
          0.696,
          0.05
        ],
        "graphga": [
          0.723,
          0.04
        ]
      },
      {
        "objective": "JNK3",
        "compose": [
          0.245,
          0.041
        ],
        "genmol": [
          0.492,
          0.01
        ],
        "ivg": [
          0.484,
          0.08
        ],
        "reinvent": [
          0.205,
          0.02
        ],
        "graphga": [
          0.244,
          0.03
        ]
      },
      {
        "objective": "Median1",
        "compose": [
          0.294,
          0.029
        ],
        "genmol": [
          0.236,
          0.0
        ],
        "ivg": [
          0.243,
          0.01
        ],
        "reinvent": [
          0.236,
          0.02
        ],
        "graphga": [
          0.222,
          0.01
        ]
      },
      {
        "objective": "Median2",
        "compose": [
          0.181,
          0.012
        ],
        "genmol": [
          0.244,
          0.0
        ],
        "ivg": [
          0.187,
          0.02
        ],
        "reinvent": [
          0.194,
          0.0
        ],
        "graphga": [
          0.211,
          0.01
        ]
      },
      {
        "objective": "Mestranol similarity",
        "compose": [
          0.503,
          0.013
        ],
        "genmol": [
          0.438,
          0.01
        ],
        "ivg": [
          0.408,
          0.02
        ],
        "reinvent": [
          0.354,
          0.04
        ],
        "graphga": [
          0.399,
          0.03
        ]
      },
      {
        "objective": "Osimertinib MPO",
        "compose": [
          0.833,
          0.027
        ],
        "genmol": [
          0.815,
          0.0
        ],
        "ivg": [
          0.783,
          0.0
        ],
        "reinvent": [
          0.776,
          0.01
        ],
        "graphga": [
          0.793,
          0.0
        ]
      },
      {
        "objective": "Perindopril MPO",
        "compose": [
          0.525,
          0.018
        ],
        "genmol": [
          0.517,
          0.01
        ],
        "ivg": [
          0.454,
          0.01
        ],
        "reinvent": [
          0.417,
          0.01
        ],
        "graphga": [
          0.471,
          0.01
        ]
      },
      {
        "objective": "QED",
        "compose": [
          0.945,
          0.002
        ],
        "genmol": [
          0.931,
          0.01
        ],
        "ivg": [
          0.936,
          0.0
        ],
        "reinvent": [
          0.94,
          0.0
        ],
        "graphga": [
          0.939,
          0.0
        ]
      },
      {
        "objective": "Ranolazine MPO",
        "compose": [
          0.77,
          0.052
        ],
        "genmol": [
          0.686,
          0.01
        ],
        "ivg": [
          0.687,
          0.02
        ],
        "reinvent": [
          0.639,
          0.01
        ],
        "graphga": [
          0.646,
          0.02
        ]
      },
      {
        "objective": "Scaffold hop",
        "compose": [
          0.461,
          0.007
        ],
        "genmol": [
          0.506,
          0.0
        ],
        "ivg": [
          0.486,
          0.01
        ],
        "reinvent": [
          0.467,
          0.0
        ],
        "graphga": [
          0.473,
          0.01
        ]
      },
      {
        "objective": "Sitagliptin MPO",
        "compose": [
          0.343,
          0.009
        ],
        "genmol": [
          0.228,
          0.02
        ],
        "ivg": [
          0.338,
          0.04
        ],
        "reinvent": [
          0.31,
          0.0
        ],
        "graphga": [
          0.332,
          0.02
        ]
      },
      {
        "objective": "Thiothixene rediscovery",
        "compose": [
          0.28,
          0.038
        ],
        "genmol": [
          0.397,
          0.01
        ],
        "ivg": [
          0.342,
          0.02
        ],
        "reinvent": [
          0.326,
          0.02
        ],
        "graphga": [
          0.323,
          0.01
        ]
      },
      {
        "objective": "Troglitazone rediscovery",
        "compose": [
          0.314,
          0.057
        ],
        "genmol": [
          0.317,
          0.01
        ],
        "ivg": [
          0.266,
          0.01
        ],
        "reinvent": [
          0.26,
          0.0
        ],
        "graphga": [
          0.287,
          0.01
        ]
      },
      {
        "objective": "Zaleplon MPO",
        "compose": [
          0.385,
          0.066
        ],
        "genmol": [
          0.46,
          0.01
        ],
        "ivg": [
          0.436,
          0.0
        ],
        "reinvent": [
          0.448,
          0.0
        ],
        "graphga": [
          0.432,
          0.01
        ]
      }
    ],
    "docking": [
      {
        "target": "PARP1",
        "lead": 1,
        "seedScore": -7.3,
        "delta04": [
          -11.9,
          -14.1,
          -10.6
        ],
        "delta06": [
          -13.6,
          -12.3,
          -10.4
        ]
      },
      {
        "target": "PARP1",
        "lead": 2,
        "seedScore": -7.8,
        "delta04": [
          -12.3,
          -13.4,
          -11.0
        ],
        "delta06": [
          -12.7,
          -11.7,
          -9.7
        ]
      },
      {
        "target": "PARP1",
        "lead": 3,
        "seedScore": -8.2,
        "delta04": [
          -14.1,
          -9.0,
          -11.3
        ],
        "delta06": [
          -11.3,
          -10.7,
          -9.2
        ]
      },
      {
        "target": "FA7",
        "lead": 1,
        "seedScore": -6.4,
        "delta04": [
          -9.3,
          -8.4,
          -8.4
        ],
        "delta06": [
          -6.4,
          -7.7,
          -7.3
        ]
      },
      {
        "target": "FA7",
        "lead": 2,
        "seedScore": -6.7,
        "delta04": [
          -9.4,
          -8.9,
          -8.4
        ],
        "delta06": [
          -7.8,
          -7.5,
          -7.6
        ]
      },
      {
        "target": "FA7",
        "lead": 3,
        "seedScore": -8.5,
        "delta04": [
          -9.6,
          -8.0,
          null
        ],
        "delta06": [
          -8.5,
          -7.4,
          null
        ]
      },
      {
        "target": "5HT1B",
        "lead": 1,
        "seedScore": -4.5,
        "delta04": [
          -12.4,
          -13.3,
          -12.9
        ],
        "delta06": [
          -13.3,
          -12.4,
          -12.1
        ]
      },
      {
        "target": "5HT1B",
        "lead": 2,
        "seedScore": -7.6,
        "delta04": [
          -11.9,
          -12.0,
          -12.3
        ],
        "delta06": [
          -12.2,
          -12.0,
          -12.0
        ]
      },
      {
        "target": "5HT1B",
        "lead": 3,
        "seedScore": -9.8,
        "delta04": [
          -12.5,
          -10.9,
          -11.6
        ],
        "delta06": [
          -10.8,
          -10.6,
          -10.5
        ]
      },
      {
        "target": "BRAF",
        "lead": 1,
        "seedScore": -9.3,
        "delta04": [
          -12.2,
          -10.1,
          -10.8
        ],
        "delta06": [
          -9.0,
          -9.7,
          null
        ]
      },
      {
        "target": "BRAF",
        "lead": 2,
        "seedScore": -9.4,
        "delta04": [
          -10.5,
          -10.8,
          -10.8
        ],
        "delta06": [
          -11.0,
          -10.4,
          -9.7
        ]
      },
      {
        "target": "BRAF",
        "lead": 3,
        "seedScore": -9.8,
        "delta04": [
          -10.9,
          -10.6,
          -10.6
        ],
        "delta06": [
          -11.5,
          -10.3,
          -10.5
        ]
      },
      {
        "target": "JAK2",
        "lead": 1,
        "seedScore": -7.7,
        "delta04": [
          -10.4,
          -10.2,
          -10.2
        ],
        "delta06": [
          -10.6,
          -9.7,
          -9.3
        ]
      },
      {
        "target": "JAK2",
        "lead": 2,
        "seedScore": -8.0,
        "delta04": [
          -11.3,
          -10.5,
          -10.0
        ],
        "delta06": [
          -10.8,
          -10.4,
          -9.4
        ]
      },
      {
        "target": "JAK2",
        "lead": 3,
        "seedScore": -8.6,
        "delta04": [
          -10.7,
          -10.2,
          -9.8
        ],
        "delta06": [
          -10.8,
          -10.3,
          null
        ]
      }
    ],
    "qed": [
      {
        "method": "COMPOSE",
        "candidates": 8,
        "success": 55.8,
        "source": "This manuscript \u00b7 446/800 sources"
      },
      {
        "method": "GrIDDD",
        "candidates": 20,
        "success": 45.1,
        "source": "Published comparison \u00b7 different source panel"
      },
      {
        "method": "MMPA",
        "candidates": 20,
        "success": 32.9,
        "source": "Jin et al. (2019)"
      },
      {
        "method": "VSeq2Seq",
        "candidates": 20,
        "success": 58.5,
        "source": "Jin et al. (2019)"
      },
      {
        "method": "VJTNN",
        "candidates": 20,
        "success": 59.9,
        "source": "Jin et al. (2019)"
      },
      {
        "method": "VJTNN+GAN",
        "candidates": 20,
        "success": 60.6,
        "source": "Jin et al. (2019)"
      },
      {
        "method": "AtomG2G",
        "candidates": 20,
        "success": 73.6,
        "source": "Jin et al. (2020)"
      },
      {
        "method": "HierG2G",
        "candidates": 20,
        "success": 76.9,
        "source": "Jin et al. (2020)"
      }
    ],
    "selection": [
      {
        "task": "Motif extension",
        "deployed": 42.63,
        "uniform": 37.2
      },
      {
        "task": "Scaffold decoration",
        "deployed": 36.7,
        "uniform": 34.47
      },
      {
        "task": "Linker design",
        "deployed": 31.53,
        "uniform": 24.0
      }
    ],
    "programAblation": [
      {
        "method": "Structured programs",
        "final": 0.621,
        "auc": 0.503
      },
      {
        "method": "Uniform legal edit chains",
        "final": 0.558,
        "auc": 0.465
      }
    ]
  }
}
